Tuesday, October 20, 2009

A Smart Grid Prime

A Smart Grid Primer                           by Bob Bruggner

I’ve been struggling all week with my own understanding of what’s being referred to as smart grid technology: that is the modernization and updating of our system for distributing and delivering electricity to consumers throughout the country.  My apologies in advance but the best analogy I could come up with to help make sense of it all was the Interstate Highway System.  So now you know what you’re in for this week if you’re still brave enough to read this entire article. Smart grids, highway systems and for good measure, I’ll start (oh boy) with a little history lesson. 

In the summer of 1919, just months after the end of World War I, a truck convoy of 81 Army vehicles set out from Washington, D.C., on a trans-continental trip to San Francisco. The trip was a preparedness test of our country’s wartime readiness and assumed damage or destruction to railroad facilities, bridges, tunnels, and highways. On the way west, the convoy experienced an endless series of mechanical difficulties, vehicles stuck in mud or sand, trucks and other equipment crashing through wooden bridges, slippery roads and harsh desert heat. Sixty-two days and 3,251 miles later, the convoy pulled into San Francisco where it members, including a young Army officer named Eisenhower, were greeted with medals, a parade, and a series of long-winded speeches. 

Nearly 40 years later, then President Dwight D. Eisenhower would successfully persuade Congress to enact the Federal-Aid Highway Act of 1956 by citing his experiences during that 1919 convoy across America as well as the appreciation he had gained for the enhanced mobility of Allied troops using the German Autobahn system as they fought their way through Germany during World War II.  The Federal-Aid Highway Act was the beginning of a cooperative federal-state undertaking that we now know as 46,876 miles of Interstate Highway System. It’s hard to imagine what life in America today would be like without our Interstate System. Our national roads provide the backbone for the distribution of goods and services, travel to and from work, vacation and business travel and, well you name it.  Nearly one-third of all miles driven in the United States use the Interstate system.

Now let’s get connect to the Smart Grid.  Think of our nation’s current power grid system as a series of independent highways designed to move traffic around local neighborhoods. Made up of over 14,000 separate transmission substations, these power grids were designed in the 60s and 70s to simply receive power, usually from a single generating source, and redistribute that power back out, in one direction, to local customers. There is little doubt that the system has served us well but imagine trying to taking a cross county trip using these local electronic highways that frequently don’t connect to one another, have different speed limits and regulations governing their use, allow travel in one direction only, and have little flexibility in handling an ever increasing amount of traffic.   

Smart grids are being promoted as a means or tool to help connect all these local roads or transmission substations into one uniform network system, allowing for intelligent communication and efficient collaboration among all components of a national grid system.   The term “smart” is really just another way of saying digital. This transformation will occur primarily through the use of digital technology and communication software which will be designed to efficiently monitor and control the availability and routing of power on a national level.

So imagine a national power grid that could draw energy on demand from not only our existing oil, coal, and nuclear plants but also from an unlimited number of small, clean, renewable energy sources located throughout the country.  This energy could then quickly be routed to any location on the national power grid as needed. Power generated at night by wind farms in Montana could be routed to customers waking up on the East Coast while electricity generated by rooftop  solar collectors in Florida could be used to help Minnesotans stay warm during those long, cold winter months.   Sounds a bit futuristic but numerous public and private initiatives are already well underway.

The cost of implementing a national smart grid system will most assuredly be expensive.  But just as President Eisenhower’s investment in an Interstate Highway System helped fuel a post-war economic boom that we continue to benefit from today, Smart grid technology will serve as a fundamental building block to a post-oil, greener, and more efficient way of meeting our countries energy needs going forward.

 

Monday, October 5, 2009

10/04 - Hogtown’s Back in the National Spotlight

Hogtown’s Back in the National Spotlight       by Bob Bruggner

It must seem like a recurring bad dream for all those other cities in the state of Florida. Once again an innovative, cutting edge initiative is underway in the city of Gainesville and it’s garnering a great deal of national and worldwide attention. No, this time it not about Urboe and the UF football team or Billy Balls’ pursuit of a third national championship or the latest research coming out of the North Florida Regional Medical Center.  No this latest initiative is the result of a partnership between the Gainesville Regional Utilities and the Gainesville City Commission which in February implemented a project making Gainesville the first city in the United States to implement a photovoltaic (PV) feed-in tariff program.  Now I know what you’re thinking;  “there’s no way a feed-in tariff program can generate the same level of excitement (or beer sales) as next weeks’ UF/LSU showdown” but participation in the program was literally sold out just weeks after the program was announced.  As a primmer and potential topic of conversation during halftime, here’s how the program works.

The City of Gainesville was searching for ways to increase the overall percentage of renewable energy they deliver customers to 20% by the year 2020. Granted, a costly and ambitious goal given the fact that electricity generated from renewable recourses such as solar are typically much more expensive than electricity currently being generated from fossil fuels. Add to this the fact that our current renewable energy policy in the U.S. consists of a complex maze of tax incentives, rebates, and state mandates making it economically impractical for states, communities and small generators to play a role in renewable electricity generation.  Note that “Profitability” is our magic word for today.  

The Gainesville Feed-in tariff program is modeled after programs that have been used successfully in Europe for years and will offer Gainesville Regional Utilities (GRU) electric customers a chance to invest in solar photovoltaic (PV) systems and sell all the electricity that they produce back to GRU. The utility will guarantee the purchase of power from participants at the above market rate of $0.32 per kilowatt-hour for a period of 20 years, in essence offering homeowners and businesses a reliable and profitable source of income while providing the incentive to producing green energy for the city.  The cost of this higher priced green energy will be coved by increasing the price of electricity per customer at a rate of $0.75 per month or about $10 a year.  A pretty good value when compared to the cost incurred by customers when utilities build new fossil fuel or nuclear facilities such as the nuclear plant proposed by Tampa Electric and Progress Energy in Levy County. Progress is seeking to raise its base rates 30 percent while adding roughly $3 to the average monthly bill to help pay for its planned nuclear plant.

In a recent NPR Marketplace interview, Gary Rowell, a tire shop owner in Gainesville, discussed his motivation for participating in the feed-in tariff initiative by installing two sets of solar panels, one on his house and one on his tire shop at a personal cost of more than $200,000. “I don't believe in global warming to 100 percent. I think it's mostly bull but I got five grandkids, and I said you know what: I'm gonna do it for them if I do nothing else.”  Mr. Rowell (remember our magic word for today?) also expects to earn $300,000 over the next 20 years and wants that money to be there when those grandkids head off to college.

Lately, there has been a great deal of discussion in Tallahassee about the qualities and characteristics of great leaders and their ability to influence a group of individuals to come together to make something extraordinary happen. Clearly, a lot of extraordinary programs continue to surface in Gainesville and dag gumit, we might all learn a little something by studying what’s going on in Hogtown.  Enjoy the game and know that your comments, ideas and suggestions are always welcome. (bbruggner@gmail.com)